Fir, Douglas (Pseudotsuga menziesii)-Needle Cast, Swiss

Cause Nothophaeocryptopus gaeumannii, a fungus found on trees of all age classes from natural forests to ornamental landscapes. Mortality is rare, but premature loss of foliage reduces growth in forest plantations, as well as in Christmas trees and in nursery stock, so that this disease can impact aesthetics, crown fullness and color, and overall tree health. The most important problem is on Christmas trees where needle quantity and quality determines saleability. The disease probably is native to the Pacific Coast but was first described in Switzerland, hence the name Swiss needle cast. Douglas-fir is the only known conifer host.

The disease became a forest problem during the 1990s in the coastal-fog zones of the northern coast range of Oregon where Douglas-fir has been planted beyond its normal range. Native and naturally regenerated stands also have severe disease development. The most heavily infected areas are around Tillamook County, Oregon up to 24 miles from the ocean. Forests from Bandon, OR to the Northern Olympic Peninsula of WA have symptoms visible from aerial surveys. Hazard zone research has shown that variables associated with increased moisture (such as fog, rainfall, and altitude), warm conditions (such as temperature during the winter), and lack of excessive heat in the summer correlate with higher disease severity. The disease is estimated to reduce mean volume growth in severe situations by 23% to 52%.

Spores produced in spring infect through the stomata of young, rapidly expanding shoots. Cool, rainy weather in spring is conducive to disease development. Symptoms and fruiting bodies of the fungus (pseudothecia) are not produced until the next spring. Production of pseudothecia was related to winter mean daily temperature and spring cumulative leaf wetness. The fungus appears to live as an endophyte within the needle and only causes disease when pseudothecia clog stomates on the underside of the needle. Needles are typically lost after 25% of the stomates are plugged.

Symptoms Infected needles usually turn off-color (light green to yellow to brown) and are prematurely cast in early spring. Needles may yellow only at the tips or be generally speckled yellow over the entire length. Current-year needles do not show symptoms. Some trees will retain infected needles and show no symptoms. Diagnostic signs are rows of black pseudothecia (pinpoint-size fruiting structures) on each side of the midrib on the lower needle surface. A hand lens is helpful in distinguishing these structures from sooty mold. Pseudothecia are most prevalent on needles 1 year old and older. Severely infected trees have only current-year needles. When displayed indoors as Christmas trees, infected trees dry out twice as fast as healthy ones.

The forestry problem, sometimes referred to as Tillamook decline, is characterized by chlorotic needles, low needle retention, and poor height and diameter growth. Trees with severe disease had narrower sapwood, narrower growth rings, higher modulus of elasticity, higher wood density, greater proportion of latewood, and lower sapwood moisture content.

Diagnosis solely based on visual symptoms is not able to distinguish Swiss needle cast from needle casts due to Phytophthora pluvialis.

Cultural control Silvicultural techniques, such as thinning and vegetation management, have been shown to have no impact on disease severity on forest trees, but will influence stand development and individual tree growth. Cultural tactics combined with chemical management are effective in Christmas tree and nursery settings.

  • Avoid planting in low-lying areas with poor air drainage.
  • Space plants for good air circulation.
  • Control weeds around the bases of trees.
  • Avoid seed from susceptible trees.
  • In heavily diseased areas, plant new forest plantations with species other than Douglas-fir.
  • Low elevation coastal provenances generally exhibit better foliage retention and growth than high elevation and interior sources.
  • Early pre-commercial thinning may be helpful to open up the forest canopy.
  • Although not tested, increase rotation lengths to accommodate for growth losses that peak when stands are in the 10- to 30-years-old range.

Chemical control Fungicides are not needed the first few years a Christmas tree is in the ground. Begin spraying 3 years before harvest. If needed, apply once when new spring growth is 1 to 2 inches long. Considering normal spring weather in the Pacific Northwest, it is better to apply fungicides a little early than too late. Although effective, the environmental and economic costs are too high for fungicides to be used in the forest setting. If used in the forest for a few years and then terminated, the disease will return to pretreatment levels within 2 to 3 years.

  • Chlorothalonil (Bravo Weather Stik, Daconil Weather Stik, Echo 720). Use Bravo Weather Stik at 2.75 to 5.5 pints/A. Excellent control under a variety of conditions. Group M5 fungicides. 12-hr reentry.
  • Heritage at 3.2 to 8 oz/A plus a non-silicone-based wetter sticker. Has not worked well in Christmas tree trials unless two (2) applications are made and disease pressure is low. Group 11 fungicide. 4-hr reentry.
  • Mancozeb-based products may not be effective under very high disease pressure. Group M3 fungicides. 24-hr reentry.
    • Dithane M45 at 2 to 4 lb/A or per 100 gal water. 14-day PHI. Registered for use on Christmas trees.
    • Fore 80 WP at 1.5 lb/100 gal water plus a spreader-sticker. Registered for outdoor or greenhouse use.
    • Penncozeb 75 DF at 2 to 4 lb/A. 14-day PHI. Registered for use on Christmas trees.
    • Protect DF at 1 to 2 lb/100 gal water plus 2 to 4 oz spreader-sticker. Registered for field, nursery, and greenhouse grown plants including Christmas trees.
  • Mural at 3.5 oz/100 gal water. Registered for ornamentals grown in nursery, greenhouse, and landscapes. Group 7 + 11 fungicide. 12-hr reentry.
  • Ortho MAX Garden Disease Control at 5 teaspoons/4 gal water. H
  • Quadris at 6 to 15.5 fl oz/A for Christmas tree use. Has not worked well in Christmas tree trials unless two (2) applications are made and disease pressure is low. Group 11 fungicide. 4-hr reentry.
  • Spectro 90 WDG at 1 to 2 lb/100 gal water. Registered for conifers grown in nursery, greenhouse, or landscape. Group 1 + M5 fungicide. 12-hr reentry.
  • Topsin 4.5 FL at 20 fl oz/50 gal water/A plus another fungicide and a spreader/sticker. May not be effective under high disease pressure. Registered for conifers including Christmas trees. Group 1 fungicide. 12-hr reentry.

Note Some research has shown that high rates of micronized sulfur can reduce the level of this disease on Douglas-fir needles. In some cases the level of disease control in the first year was similar to that obtained with chlorothalonil but not as good in the second year. The use of sulfur is not recommended at this time

Reference Shaw, D.C., Filip, G.M., Kanaskie, A., Maguire, D.A. and Littke, W.A. 2011. Managing an epidemic of Swiss needle cast in the Douglas-fir region of Oregon: The role of the Swiss Needle Cast Cooperative. Journal of Forestry 109:109-119.