Walnut (Juglans spp.)-Thousand Cankers Disease {Black Walnut Decline}

PNW Plant Handbook Article Image

There are numerous dead branches in the crown of all these trees. All of the trees were removed within 5 years.

PNW Plant Disease Image

These 3 black walnut trees have different amounts of Thousand Cankers Disease. The tree on the right is almost dead and should be cut down. Tree on the left has very little dieback and does not need management. Tree in the middle could use some pruning; if dieback continues then one might consider removal.

PNW Plant Handbook Article Image
The fungus Geosmithia was isolated from the discolored cambium associated with these beetle galleries.
PNW Plant Handbook Article Image
Dieback in this tree was followed down the trunk to this margin where dead black cambium above (right) meets healthy cambium below. We suggest to prune below this margin.
PNW Plant Handbook Article Image
Early symptoms of dieback in this black walnut tree.

Cause A fungal disease (Geosmithia morbida), vectored by the walnut twig beetle (Pityophthorus juglandis), that can cause death of black walnut (Juglans nigra). The disease has been detected in many Western States including eastern Washington, Idaho, and throughout Oregon on both sides of the Cascade Range. Several quarantines of plants, wood and wood products have been established in some of the states in the Eastern United States. It was first noticed in Oregon during the early 1990's. Most of the trees impacted at that time were on poorly drained soils in the mid-Willamette Valley area. The majority of the problem seemed to have occurred over a 3-year period. There were few complaints about this problem until 2001 when this dieback occurred on a wide variety of soil types, including productive agricultural soils, in the Portland metropolitan area. Beyond the Pacific Northwest it has now been confirmed in Ohio, Tennessee, North Carolina, and Italy.

The canker causing fungus Geosmithia morbida has been found in association with walnut twig beetles and their galleries. Armillaria root rot has also been found along with declining trees. It has been hypothesized that the phloem-limited cankers starve the trees for nutrients and reserves thereby weakening them and encouraging other diseases and winter injury to ultimately kill the tree. Phytoplasma testing during the 08 growing season was negative and remains an unlikely cause of this problem.

Small diameter black walnut (Juglans nigra) trees in Colorado died within one to two years after first symptoms were observed. Decline and death occurs much more slowly in the PNW on large diameter black walnut hybrids (J. nigra X J. hindsii). Young, small diameter trees found growing near declining trees have remained symptomless. Western black walnut species may host both insect and fungus, show minor symptoms or even appear to recover in succeeding years. Preliminary testing found J. nigra to be much more susceptible than J. hindsii or other Juglans species. This may account for the different disease progression in different areas. English walnuts (J. regia) are not as susceptible but the disease is easily found in English walnut orchards

Symptoms The dominant symptom is that branches fail to leaf out in the spring. Branches may leaf out very weakly in the spring or, less often, die anytime during the summer. Some trees will express sudden dead wood and/or progression of symptoms during the growing season. Generally dead leaves do not remain on the declining branches. Dieback always appears to start in the upper crown and progresses to lower branches in succeeding years. Some trees appear to have top dieback appearing almost concurrently with limb dieback at various places throughout the crown. Some trees may exhibit a thin canopy with few yellowing leaves. Trees may die within 2 to 5 years once symptoms are noticed but the majority, experience a slow dieback over many years. This problem has been observed mostly in mature trees of large diameter (DBH).

Carefully remove the bark from symptomatic limbs to find cankers. When peeling the bark, do not cut too deeply as beetle galleries and fungi are found in the living bark (cork cambium and not the wood cambium). Individual cankers may at first be only a few millimeters in diameter, but ultimately can be 3 cm or greater and have an elongate oval shape. Typically the appearance of a shallow tunnel produced by the walnut twig beetle will be present near the center of the canker. Many small, dark, dead areas (cankers) can be found under the bark of heavily infected trees. The cumulative effect of innumerable cankers produces limb girdling that cause dieback.

No witches' brooms have been observed on declining trees. Sometimes epicormic shoots will be seen but if present they are not abundant, except in The Dalles, Oregon where epicormic shoots are very numerous. Declining trees do not consistently have visible trunk cankers, heart rots, butt rots, storm damage, commercial pruning or herbicide use in common.

Cultural control None is known. Although the disease has similarities to Dutch elm disease, similar control tactics are not warranted. The disease is not expected to be root graft transmissible, which would require removal of adjacent trees. Quick removal of infected trees once identified is also not expected to be necessary.

  • A set of 2 trees in each of 2 locations (for a total of 4 trees) that were topped or pruned hard due to their location under power lines have remained healthy while nearby trees that were not pruned declined or died. This indicates that pruning hard (lower on the branch or trunk) may help trees that exhibit less extensive dieback. It is suggested to remove limbs below the margin found between necrotic and healthy cambium.
  • If trees continue to dieback the following year then tree owners might consider selling their trees for lumber to recoup pruning and tree removal costs.
  • Do not sell or transport firewood or logs with intact bark from infected trees to areas without the problem. Logs can remain a source of both beetle and fungus for at least 18 months.

Chemical control None is known. Research on insecticides and/or fungicides applied to the trunk, crown or soil or injected into the tree has not been done. Most experts agree that these applications would have minimal if any effect on disease progression. In Colorado, infested black walnut trees that have received repeated commercial insecticide treatments have continued to decline and die.

It is not known if treatments to control powder post beetle on lumber will also control walnut twig beetle.

Injection of bactericides for the control of phytoplasma is not justified.

References Pscheidt, J.W. 2011. Disease progress of thousand cankers disease in Oregon. Phytopathology 101:S146.

Utley, C., Nguyen, T., Roubtsova, T., Coggeshall, M., Ford, T.M., Grauke, L.J., Graves, A.D., Leslie, C.A., McKenna, J., Woeste, K., Yaghmour, M.A., Cranshaw, W., Seybold, S.J., Bostock, R.M., and Tisserat, N. 2013. Susceptibility of walnut and hickory species to Geosmithia morbida. Plant Dis. 97:601-607.